Roof Repair vs. Replacement in Winter

Blog Layout

Roof Repair vs. Replacement: How to Decide During Winter Months in Philadelphia

January 18, 2025

Winter in Philadelphia brings snow, ice, and freezing temperatures, making roofing decisions more challenging. If your roof shows signs of damage, you might wonder: Should I repair it or replace it? At Sterner Brothers Roofing, we help homeowners make the right choice for their home and budget—even in the coldest months!

Signs You Need a Roof Repair

If your roof has minor issues but is still structurally sound, repairs can extend its lifespan. Consider a repair if you notice:

✅ Missing or Damaged Shingles – A few missing shingles due to wind or ice damage can often be replaced.

✅ Small Leaks – If water is seeping in but hasn’t caused widespread damage, a patch or flashing repair may be enough.

✅ Minor Ice Dam Damage – If ice dams cause localized damage, targeted repairs can prevent further issues.

✅ Mild Wear & Tear – If your roof is under 15 years old and in good condition except for small problem areas.

Winter Consideration: Repairs are possible in winter, but adhesives may take longer to cure in cold temperatures. Sterner Brothers Roofing uses specialized materials to ensure durability even in freezing weather.

Signs You Need a Full Roof Replacement

Sometimes, repairs just aren’t enough. A full replacement may be necessary if you experience:

🚨 Frequent or Widespread Leaks – Multiple leaks indicate deeper structural issues.

🚨 Severe Ice Dam Damage – Ice dams can lift shingles, allowing water to penetrate underlayment.

🚨 Sagging Roof – If parts of your roof sag, the structure underneath may be failing.

🚨 Roof is 20+ Years Old – Older roofs are more prone to failure, especially during harsh winters.

Winter Consideration: While full roof replacements in winter are more challenging due to temperature-sensitive materials, Sterner Brothers Roofing uses cold-weather installation techniques to ensure a high-quality finish.

Challenges of Winter Roofing in Philadelphia

Philadelphia’s winter weather can complicate roofing work, but with the right techniques, we ensure a safe and durable installation. Key challenges include:

🌡️ Cold Temperatures – Shingles become brittle in freezing conditions, requiring extra care.

❄️ Snow & Ice – Work may be delayed due to heavy snowfall or ice buildup.

💨 Shorter Days – Fewer daylight hours mean roofing projects may take longer.

How We Overcome These Challenges:

At Sterner Brothers Roofing, we use winter-friendly roofing techniques, including:

✔️ Special adhesives that work in cold temperatures.

✔️ Hand-sealing shingles to prevent wind damage.

✔️ Careful scheduling to take advantage of warmer days.

Cost Considerations: Repair vs. Replacement

💰 Repairs – Less expensive upfront but may be a temporary fix if your roof is near the end of its lifespan.

💰 Replacement – Higher upfront cost but provides long-term savings by preventing repeated repairs.

If you're unsure which option is best, Sterner Brothers Roofing offers free inspections to assess your roof's condition and recommend the best course of action.

Final Decision: Repair or Replace?

🔹 Choose repair if: Your roof has minor damage, is relatively new, and the structure is still strong.

🔹 Choose replacement if: Your roof is old, has widespread damage, or leaks are recurring.

Still unsure? Sterner Brothers Roofing can help! Our experts assess your roof and provide honest recommendations tailored to your home’s needs.

Schedule a Winter Roof Inspection Today!

Don’t wait until small issues turn into major problems. Whether you need a quick repair or a full replacement, Sterner Brothers Roofing is here to help Philadelphia homeowners stay protected this winter.

📞 Call us now: (215)914-5174

< Older Post Newer Post >